
I grew up a good Midwestern Protestant child and I’m sure this was the picture posted in every Sunday School room on every Palm Sunday of my little life. Jesus in a white outfit on a cute donkey. The first step in what turns out to be a pretty eventful week. Which, as every Sunday School kid knows, ends in the Glory of Easter Sunday when the stone is rolled away and our salvation is made Real. Holy Week is something you just have to get through; the prize at the end is worth it.
Becoming Catholic, I learned about the value of Jesus’ suffering in a different way. I started contemplating the mysteries of Holy Week, the Stations of the Cross, and started to see each event, no matter now humiliating and painful, as important in itself and not just the means to an end. I started to think of Easter as a refreshing rain, cleaning away the stains and invigorating the start of life everlasting.
It’s taken a lifetime, then, for me to arrive at this point. I’ve given contemplation and meditation my sincere best. But this year the questions come rushing back and for once I can’t ignore them: What does Holy Week say about being human? I see Jesus barreling towards heaven, but is there a message in this about human life on Earth? To me, the notion of the Incarnation is one of the holiest things I can imagine–and I can only barely imagine it. God made human. God willingly entering human existence. God partaking in everyday life. This is touching beyond belief.
The plot advances. The second person of the Trinity, Jesus, grows up in obscurity and starts traveling at the age of 30. His message is provocative. People in authority don’t like him. He doesn’t care. He knows they will kill him. The last week of his life rolls around, and when he is confronted by the people who don’t like him he gets sullen and sassy–at least that’s what my mother would say if she made a comment about how we were acting and we replied, “You say that’s what I am!” On the cross, Jesus has no time for the thief who is obviously frightened out of his mind and asking awkwardly for some help, but he offers relief to the guy who notices he’s been framed. Is this where the mystery of the Incarnation has been headed all along? You can’t wait to become human, then you can’t wait to get out of the human condition.
The Jesus stories all have to mean something. There are lots of twists and turns. A sort of narrative cohesion develops in the Gospels, but it’s not seamless. As a reader, as a thinker, one is anxious the whole way through. This makes for a rich lifetime of meditation. It can also make for some very lazy thinking: let someone else interpret what’s going on and hang onto it with all you’ve got. The meaning of the Easter story, I was told, is that God loved us so he died in our place to atone for our sins. He came to show He loves us. He came as one of us.
Nobody wants to talk about the inconsistencies, the questions left unanswered. Jesus sat on the donkey and everybody loved him. By Friday afternoon, he was dead. One of the messages I’m getting out of this is if I’m defiant, I’ll pay a price. Even if I have approval, I can’t count on loyalty. Friends will let you down. Prayer might be painful. The Incarnation to Calvary progression points to a failure in the human experiment (for this insight I’m in debt to Jack Miles, though I’m not accurately paraphrasing his work). We, as created beings, might have once been delightful but in this story we are disappointing, corrupt betrayers. Original sin notwithstanding, it feels a bit like a set-up.
Which, I guess, is where faith comes in. So I’ll try to look toward Easter with the eyes of faith once more. I’m not afraid of doubt and healthy skepticism. I’m not worried if it doesn’t make sense–and I’m willing to admit it doesn’t. The Jesus story is a tough one and this week’s episodes are some of the toughest. I can hardly wait ’til Sunday.

