
My mother’s method of Thanksgiving preparations can be analyzed several ways: she used paper plates and pre-cooked turkey because she was practical OR she used paper plates and pre-cooked turkey because she was cold hearted, unsentimental, and couldn’t be bothered with the Real Thing. For years, I nursed the latter point of view. I wanted the Norman Rockwell Thanksgiving: turkey carved at the table, gleaming silverware, clink of glasses, shining smiles all ’round. And, by God, that’s what I’ve done since the feast was mine to make–at least twenty-five of them or so over the last thirty years.
Now, on Day 6 of turkey, I’m moved to reassess. There are still neat piles of china plates on the sideboard, waiting to be put back into the china closet. There’s a basket of white linen napkins and a huge damask cloth that should be ironed before I put them away. I have no idea what I’m going to do with the last blob of mashed potatoes since I’ve already made potato bread, potato pancakes, and heated them up in the microwave to “use up the gravy.” And so on. Somehow over the years I’ve managed to ignore the enormity of the Thanksgiving I create, but this year it’s catching up with me.
I still love each gesture of the holiday: the careful shopping; the excessive, semi-competitive baking (this year I produced four pies, a dozen rolls, a loaf of bread, AND a cheesecake–what about YOU?); fussing over the table setting and seating arrangements; making the centerpiece; ironing guest towels, touching up that huge pile of napkins; unfurling the perfect white tablecloth. I love to open the silver chest and see the gleaming knife handles, straight as soldiers above piles of spoons and forks. I love choosing the wine, composing h’ors d’oeuvres plates, setting my grandmother’s butter knife on the Boda plate as I’ve done so many times before. This year, for the first time, I felt the cumulative effect of these gestures and it felt like work. I’m still exhausted. How did I do all of this when I was working full time?
Well, for one thing, I was younger and busier. Somehow, being busy makes even huge efforts seem all in a day’s work. The more you have to do, the more you’re able to do–at least for a while. I’ve been slowed down by age and circumstance. Being slower means having more time to reflect. Hmmmmm. Maybe there are options.
My first impulse is to declare next Thanksgiving a Chinet-football-turkey pizza kind of event where I do nothing more strenuous than hang up the coats. I imagine a rolicking time in a dirty house with huge plastic garbage bags at the curb the next afternoon. Or I could become cold hearted and unsentimental, cook the turkey ahead of time in a foil pan, leave my china in the cupboard, and play a little Montivani in the background (thanks, Mom). Or I could look at the whole business as greater than the sum of its parts, a production worth the toil, a beachhead against the erosion of civilized behavior. I could just give thanks for the accumulation of memories, good and bad, garlanded all around that gleaming table. I’m ambivalent. But Christmas is right around the corner…
In the meantime, here’s my recipe for a turkey salad that I believe makes everything else about the leftovers worthwhile:
Turkey Salad
4 cups chopped cooked turkey
1 cup chopped celery
1 cup toasted slivered almonds
1/2 cup chopped dried cherries
1 tsp. salt
1 tsp. dried tarragon
1 1/2 cups mayonnaise
3 tbsp. white vinegar
3 tbsp. sugar
2-3 tbsp. milk or cream, to make desired consistency
Mix all ingredients and chill before serving.