
If you have a story in your imagination about life in Vermont, it probably goes something like this: You move to Vermont when life “below” gets just too hectic and materialistic. You find a scraggy piece of land and carve out a nice garden, which you fertilize with homemade compost. You build your own house of native materials–maybe the rocks you pick as you clear garden space. You find some kind of homegrown skill or product you can use for income–maybe you raise organic produce, or you make furniture, something like that. You gather with your like-minded friends to play music, sing, and dance. You create your wardrobe and household furnishings from stuff you find, or swap, or buy at the thrift store. You eat a vegan diet, most of which comes from your own garden, though you do have to buy the organic tofu from the coop. In all of this, you find a sane balance lacking in the “real” world, which you gladly leave behind.
This mythology lives on in large part due to the lives of Helen and Scott Nearing, urban intellectuals who came to Vermont during the Great Depression of the 1930′s and wrote about this lifestyle: “the good life.” The Nearings bought a tumbledown farm at the base of Stratton Mountain and started a maple sugaring operation there. They built their own house and outbuildings, had the dream garden, made music. Their philosophy was the “four-four-four” plan, being four hours of “bread labor”–the work needed for income, four hours of work on the homestead, and four hours of personal enrichment such as music and writing every day. This plan, they insisted, could restore a human to a level of sanity not attainable in the rushing world of market capitalism.

Their romantic vision,as outlined in their book Living the Good Life, was irresistable and soon hundreds of pilgrims flocked to the little farm to learn more. The Nearings welcomed the pilgrims and put quite a few of them to work, ostensibly “learning the ropes.” The homestead flourished with the added attention. The Nearings, gaining momentum, tried to engage the neighbors in their enterprise. Here’s where the myth gets a few frayed edges. The neighbors, being old Vermonters, weren’t impressed. They didn’t think of their way of life (which, let’s face it, existed long before the Nearings arrived on the scene) as all that precious and some of them were actually looking forward to availing themselves of a few modern conveniences. Heavens.
So the Nearings moved to Maine, started over in another spot, still utilizing their “four-four-four” method, and wrote Continuing the Good Life. More acolytes followed. Eventually, those around them started to spill the beans. Scott lived on trust-fund money. The move-up hippies who came to visit them ended up doing all the work. The Nearings went on book lecture tours every winter because their Maine stone house was too cold and drafty. Though they protested “animal slavery” and wouldn’t do things like keeping bees, it turns out Helen had a pet cat. They went out for ice cream from time to time. The had feet of clay, as it turns out.

Still, it all sounds so good. The “four-four-four” method seems as though it should work. I’m able to see a few lingering outlines of the Nearings’ thinking in activities around me. Most of us in Vermont live on the grid, work outside our homes, and participate fully in mainstream culture (that is, we watch TV as much as everybody else does). However, we are a bit more skeptical of “progess,” we remember the analog ways of doing things even if we don’t use them as much, we’ve never really stopped “reducing, reusing, and recycling.” I can allow for the Nearings’ imperfections. They made the simple ways seem noble, and I’m grateful to them for that.

It’s sugaring season again and I think of the Nearings’ operation. I imagine somebody is working that sugarbush at the base of Stratton Mountain, still dumping buckets (or emptying tanks linked by plastic lines) and boiling the sap pretty much the same way they did it. There are plenty of people starting greens in cold frames, planning their organic gardens, and turning the compost. Lots of neighbors still swap tools and children’s clothes and get together for contradancing on Saturday nights. I’m happy to live in a place where living the good life still seems possible, even though we know it’s a lot of hard work and not all of us are going to have disciples or trust funds. At least we can still go out for ice cream.